A novated lease on a new electric vehicle can deliver significant tax advantages – and that’s exactly why many Australian employees are considering them. But beneath the headline numbers are pitfalls that can erode, or even exceed, those savings. After recently arranging a novated lease myself, I discovered first-hand how a generous FBT exemption for zero-emissions vehicles can be undermined by less obvious costs. This guide explains what to look for, the questions to ask, and alternatives to consider before you sign.

What is a novated lease – and why are EVs attractive under it?

• A novated lease is a salary-sacrifice arrangement where lease repayments are deducted from your pre-tax income. That reduces your taxable salary and can produce substantial income tax savings.
• Normally, using a company-provided vehicle for personal use attracts fringe benefits tax (FBT). Leasing structures often include employee post-tax contributions to reduce FBT exposure.
• For eligible zero-emissions vehicles (EVs) current government concessions mean the FBT treatment is more favourable – allowing some employees to fund a novated lease predominantly from pre-tax income. That can extend to running costs such as registration, insurance, charging, servicing and other eligible expenses.
• For people in higher tax brackets, these concessions can translate into savings worth tens of thousands over the life of the lease – which is why demand is surging.

Why the headline tax benefit can be misleading

The tax savings are real, but they are only part of the picture. When you factor in financing costs, insurance, lease fees and the structure of the novated arrangement, the apparent bargain can evaporate.

Key issues to watch

Interest rate – ask and insist on clarity

• Novated leases often attract higher interest rates than conventional car loans. Unlike a bank loan where the interest rate is clear and prominent, many novated lease quotes show only the repayment amount and hide the underlying rate.
• In my case the initial rate was around 11.5% – markedly higher than the roughly 7% available on a standard car loan at the time. Once we asked and negotiated, the rate came down by more than two percentage points, saving over $1,000 a year.
• Action: Always ask the leasing company for the exact interest rate and the method used to calculate repayments. Insist on a full cost breakdown (interest, fees, residual value, establishment fees).

Fixed interest rates for the lease term

• Novated lease interest rates are typically fixed for the life of the lease (often up to five years). If official rates fall during that term – as many economists forecast they could – you won’t benefit unless you refinance.
• That contrasts with some alternatives such as variable-rate car loans or adding finance to your mortgage, which may track reductions in market interest rates.
• Action: Consider your view on interest-rate movements and whether you might be locked into a rate that becomes uncompetitive.

Limited choice of leasing provider

• Employers commonly contract with one leasing company (or a small panel) to manage novated leases. That reduces administrative burden for payroll, but it also limits your ability to shop for better finance rates or more flexible packages.
• If your employer only deals with a single provider, the ability to negotiate is constrained – and the leasing company knows it.
• Action: Ask your employer about their supplier panel. If you have flexibility, negotiate for the ability to use an alternate provider or to have the employer consider a wider panel.

Insurance can be packaged – and expensive

• Leasing providers often bundle insurance to simplify the process, but the premiums can be high. In my case the insurer tied to the lease quoted several thousand dollars per year, while the same level of cover from a mainstream insurer cost less than a third of that.
• The novated process complicates matters: the insurance usually needs to be finalised after the lease is signed, but finance release is contingent on insurance being in place. If you want to source your own policy to save money, you’ll often need a cover note pre-delivery and then pay once the vehicle is parked at your home.
• Action: Get insurance quotes independently before finalising a lease. Ask the leasing provider whether you can supply your own policy and what documentation they require.

Fees, administration and residual values

• Novated leases include establishment fees, administration charges and possibly higher residual values that affect repayments. These items are sometimes buried in the quote.
• Leases can also include conditions on early termination, damage, excess wear and tear – and those costs can be material at the end of the lease.
• Action: Request a full schedule of fees, buy-back/residual value terms and early termination costs. Compare out-of-pocket and end-of-lease scenarios with a financed purchase.

Total cost of ownership vs tax savings

• It’s tempting to focus on the headline tax savings, but the correct comparison is total cost of ownership (TCO) over the lease term: repayments plus interest, insurance, fees, running costs and any end-of-lease liabilities, compared with alternatives such as a car loan, mortgage top-up or paying cash.
• In some cases – especially where financing is expensive, or insurance is overpriced – you may be better off taking a standard car loan or purchasing the vehicle outright.
• Action: Build a side-by-side costing over the full term (typically five years) that includes all likely expenses.

Practical checklist before you sign

• Ask for the interest rate, how repayments are calculated and whether any component is outsourced to a financier.
• Obtain independent insurance quotes and confirm whether you can use your own provider.
• Get a full breakdown of fees (establishment, administration, monthly fees, end-of-lease costs).
• Confirm the residual (balloon) amount and what happens at lease end.
• Ask whether the rate is fixed and if there are options to refinance or exit early.
• Compare the novated lease TCO against a standard car loan, mortgage top-up and cash purchase.
• Negotiate: simply asking the right questions can reduce the interest rate and save you thousands.

Alternatives to consider

• Standard car loan from a bank or credit union – often cheaper interest rates and more transparent terms.
• Mortgage top-up – if you have capacity, sometimes lower interest and the ability to consolidate.
• Personal loan – may offer competitive rates for shorter terms.
• Buying outright with cash – avoids interest and many ongoing fees.
• Salary packaging non-vehicle benefits – if your employer offers broader salary-sacrifice options, mix and match benefits to suit your financial position.

Who benefits most?

• Employees in the highest tax brackets generally gain the biggest tax advantage from salary sacrifice arrangements.
• However, without careful comparison, the higher financing costs and packaged services can wipe out those advantages. Novated leases suit those who value convenience and bundled services, and who can secure competitive finance and insurance within the employer’s approved providers.

Conclusion

Novated leasing for electric vehicles offers a compelling route to leverage Australia’s FBT concessions and reduce your taxable income. But it is not an automatic win. Interest rates, fixed terms, limited provider panels, insurance mark-ups and hidden fees can all erode the tax benefits. Do the legwork: demand transparent interest rates, compare total cost of ownership against other finance options, and shop insurance independently. With the right questions and careful comparison, a novated lease can be highly beneficial – but without that diligence it can easily cost you more.

FAQs

Q: What is a novated lease?

A: A novated lease is a three-way salary-sacrifice arrangement between you, your employer and a leasing company. Lease repayments are deducted from your pre-tax salary, potentially reducing your taxable income.

Q: How does the FBT exemption for EVs help?

A: Current concessions for eligible zero-emissions vehicles can reduce or remove fringe benefits tax for novated leases, allowing more of the lease costs to be funded from pre-tax income. This can lower your tax bill and increase savings, particularly for higher earners.

Q: Are novated leases cheaper than car loans?

A: Not necessarily. While tax savings can be significant, novated lease interest rates and fees are often higher than standard car loans. Compare total cost of ownership, not just the tax benefit.

Q: Can I choose my own leasing provider?

A: Often not. Employers commonly use a single leasing provider or a small panel to simplify payroll processing. Ask your employer about approved providers and whether exceptions are possible.

Q: Can I use my own insurance?

A: Possibly, but it can complicate the process. Leasing providers usually require insurance to be arranged once the lease is signed and before finance is released. You may need a cover note for delivery and then finalise the policy once the car is in your possession.

Q: What happens if interest rates fall during my lease?

A: Most novated lease rates are fixed for the term, so you won’t automatically benefit from future rate reductions. That’s why comparing fixed-rate lease costs against variable-rate loan options is important.

Q: What should I compare before signing?

A: Compare interest rates, fees, insurance costs, residual/balloon values, end-of-lease conditions, and total cost of ownership over the lease term against alternative finance options.

Q: Who benefits most from novated leasing?

A: Typically higher-income employees who can access the full tax-saving potential, and those who value the convenience of bundled services – provided they secure competitive finance and insurance terms.

About EV Evolution

EV Evolution is the leading online platform dedicated to Australian electric vehicle owners and enthusiasts. We foster a vibrant community, delivering essential EV news and insights, and enhancing user engagement through our innovative, AI-powered chatbot for dynamic discussions. Our mission is to empower Australian electric vehicle owners and enthusiasts by fostering a vibrant, AI-driven online community that connects, informs, and advances the nation’s electric vehicle landscape.